E&I Members: How likely are you to recommend E&I Cooperative Services to a peer?

Takes less than sixty seconds

Spend Analysis Consultants vs. a Cooperative Assessment: What Education Buyers Actually Need

Does it seem like you’re working harder these days? It’s not your imagination. 58% of procurement teams report significantly increased workloads, yet only 13% have seen any increases in staffing in 2026.

For procurement leaders in higher education, those numbers probably feel familiar. Institutions are facing ongoing budget pressures, rising expectations from campus stakeholders, and increasing demands for compliance and transparency. At the same time, procurement teams are often being asked to identify new savings opportunities without additional personnel or resources.

As a result, many colleges and universities are looking more closely at their spending data.

Higher Ed Needs Better Spend Visibility

Many colleges and universities operate in decentralized purchasing environments where departments purchase similar products and services from different suppliers, creating fragmented spending patterns that are difficult to track and manage.

Limited spend visibility can also create hidden costs, including:

  • Off-contract purchases
  • Duplicate suppliers
  • Inconsistent pricing
  • Missed sourcing opportunities

 

Improving spend visibility is often the first step toward building a more strategic procurement function.

What Do Spend Analysis Consultants Do?

Spend analysis consultants and spend analysis providers help organizations collect, cleanse, categorize, and analyze purchasing data. Their objective is to identify spending patterns, sourcing opportunities, supplier consolidation opportunities, and areas where organizations may be able to reduce costs or improve procurement performance.

There are some pros and cons.

Potential Benefits

Potential Drawbacks

Detailed spend visibility across categories and suppliers

Consulting engagements can be expensive

Data-driven recommendations for sourcing opportunities

Projects may require significant internal support and data preparation

Improved reporting and benchmarking capabilities

Recommendations still require time and resources to implement

Identification of supplier consolidation opportunities

Analysis alone does not automatically generate savings

Greater understanding of procurement trends and spending patterns

Additional consulting support may be needed to execute recommendations

 

Cost is also a factor. Spend analysis consultants aren’t cheap.

E&I’s No-Cost Strategic Spend Assessments

Unlike spend analysis providers, E&I Cooperative Services offers no-cost Strategic Spend Assessments (SSAs) to its members. SSAs go beyond identifying where spending occurs by evaluating how spending compares with cooperative contracts. This can uncover immediate savings opportunities, often with suppliers you may already be working with. By adopting one of E&I’s competitively solicited cooperative contracts, you may be able to benefit from volume discounts achieved by combining demand across thousands of other academic institutions.

E&I assigns a dedicated Sourcing Consultant and Strategic Sourcing Analyst to analyze your high-level spend data. You do not need to provide transaction-level detail, so the data gathering process is usually simple, exporting AP and card transactions from your financial systems. All data is kept confidential.

Strategic Spend Assessments focus on several key areas to uncover hidden savings opportunities:

  • Examining existing commodity spend to find cost savings by bringing more spend under contract.
  • Evaluating contracted spend with the strength of E&I’s comparable contract.
  • Looking for areas where consolidating suppliers can reduce administrative burdens and achieve better pricing.
  • Find areas where spending volume can improve potential patronage distribution from E&I.

Using both current contracts and upcoming RFPs, we can help you identify future alignment opportunities to further reduce your procurement costs.

Leveraging Total Economic Benefit

Beyond identifying potential savings, the assessment helps institutions understand the broader economic impact of procurement decisions.

The E&I Economic Benefit ModelTM is built into every contract to help you see the total value derived. This includes accounting for:

  • Cost reduction
  • Cost avoidance
  • Incentives and revenue opportunities

 

Choosing Your Path: Spend Analysis Consultant vs. E&I SSA

To help you evaluate the best approach for your institution’s resources, here is how a traditional consulting engagement stacks up against an E&I Strategic Spend Assessment across key procurement metrics.

Feature / Capability

Spend Analysis Consultants

E&I Strategic Spend Assessment

Upfront Cost

High

No-Cost for member institutions

Staff Time Required

Heavy (Months of data cleaning & IT support)

Minimal (Simple AP/P-card data export)

Primary Deliverable

Static report or software dashboard

Actionable contract alignment roadmap

Execution Support

None (Your team must run the resulting RFPs)

Immediate (Access to pre-solicited contracts)

Higher Ed Expertise

Generalist or corporate-focused

100% dedicated to education procurement

 

E&I Cooperative Services is the only nonprofit, member-owned sourcing cooperative that focuses exclusively on the education sector. Working on behalf of more than 6,200 academic institutions, E& provides a range of services to help procurement teams maximize spend, including access to more than 215 competitively solicited cooperative agreements.

To get started with a no-cost Strategic Spend Assessment, contact your E&I rep today. If your institution is not already a member, register to become one. Membership is free and there is no minimum purchasing requirement.

WE USE COOKIES

We use cookies to make your experience better!

Skip to content